Harless Claims and Public-Policy Wrongful Discharge in West Virginia

Harless Claims and Public-Policy Wrongful Discharge in West Virginia

West Virginia is generally an at-will employment state. That means an employer can often end a job for a good reason, a poor reason, or no reason — but not for a reason that breaks the law or contravenes a substantial public policy.

In Harless v. First National Bank in Fairmont (1978), West Virginia’s highest court recognized that an at-will employee may have a common-law claim when the employer’s motivation for the discharge is to contravene some substantial public policy principle. That idea is often called a Harless claim. It is not a claim for every unfair firing, and we cannot say in advance whether it would apply to any particular job loss.

Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC represents employees in wrongful-termination disputes, including cases in which a public-policy theory may be part of the discussion. If you want to talk, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482.

Related pages: Wrongful Termination · Retaliation for Reporting · Workplace Discrimination · Employment Law · Contact

What “substantial public policy” means, in plain terms

A Harless claim depends on a public policy that is substantial and clearly recognized. West Virginia cases have looked to the state constitution, statutes, legislatively approved regulations, and judicial opinions as sources of that policy. A personal sense that the firing was unfair is not enough, standing alone. See, among other cases, Williamson v. Greene (1997).

Examples that have been discussed in West Virginia cases include, in appropriate facts, policies reflected in the Human Rights Act — including sex discrimination and sexual harassment — and policies reflected in the federal Family and Medical Leave Act. See Williamson v. Greene (1997) and Burke v. Wetzel County Commission (2018). Those examples are not a complete list, and they are not a promise that the same theory will fit a new set of facts.

How this relates to other claims

A Harless theory is sometimes considered when a statute does not cover the employer (for example, an employer below the Human Rights Act’s coverage threshold) or when a related statutory claim is also in the case. Statutory and common-law claims may, in some situations, proceed together, subject to rules against recovering twice for the same harm. Whether that is so in a particular matter depends on the facts and the law.

If you were fired after you reported discrimination or harassment, also see our retaliation and wrongful termination pages.

Deadlines and next steps

Time limits for common-law and statutory claims can differ, and they can be short. Do not wait to get advice. This page cannot calculate your deadline. Write down a timeline, keep messages and personnel documents, and be careful about signing a severance or release before you understand it.

Talk with the firm

If you would like to discuss what happened and whether we may be able to help, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482, or use our contact form. There is no charge for an initial consultation.

Many of our employment and injury cases are handled on a contingency-fee basis. That means our attorney’s fee is a percentage of any recovery and is owed only if there is a recovery. Fees, costs, and expenses are explained in a written agreement before you hire us. Some matters are not contingency cases. We will tell you if that applies to your situation.

Contacting the firm — by phone, text, email, or this website — does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only after the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.

Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC
213 Hale Street, Suite 100
Charleston, WV 25301
Office: (681) 215-0642 · Text: (304) 767-9482 · Fax: (304) 648-4521

Frequently asked questions

What is a Harless claim?

It is a West Virginia common-law claim for wrongful discharge when an at-will employee is fired to contravene a substantial public policy. The leading case is Harless v. First National Bank in Fairmont (1978). Not every unfair firing qualifies. The public policy must be substantial and clearly recognized, often from a constitution, statute, regulation, or judicial opinion.

Does a Harless claim replace a Human Rights Act claim?

Not necessarily. In some situations the two may be discussed together, and in some situations a Harless theory is considered when a statute does not cover the employer or the exact problem. Whether both can proceed, and how double recovery is avoided, depends on the facts and the law. We cannot say in advance which theories, if any, would apply.

Can FMLA leave support a Harless claim?

West Virginia’s highest court has allowed a retaliatory-discharge claim premised on the public policy reflected in the federal Family and Medical Leave Act to go forward at the pleading stage, depending on the facts. That is not a promise that every FMLA-related firing is a Harless case. Coverage and eligibility under the FMLA are specific. See Burke v. Wetzel County Commission (2018).

What if my employer is too small for the Human Rights Act?

In some sex-discrimination or sexual-harassment situations, an at-will employee of an employer below the Act’s coverage threshold may still have a common-law retaliatory-discharge claim. See Williamson v. Greene (1997). Whether that applies depends on the size of the employer and the facts.

I was not fired — I resigned. Can Harless still apply?

In some cases a resignation may be treated as a discharge if conditions were so intolerable that a reasonable person would feel compelled to quit, and those conditions were tied to the unlawful conduct. That is a demanding standard and is fact-specific. This page cannot decide that question.

Disclaimer

This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. It is not a complete statement of West Virginia or federal law. Deadlines are strict and can be shorter than you expect, and the facts of your situation matter. Past results do not predict the outcome of any case. Visiting this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship until the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.


Call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482. Phones are answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Or use the contact form.