Workplace Injury and Deliberate Intent Claims in West Virginia

Workplace Injury and Deliberate Intent Claims in West Virginia

If you were hurt on the job in West Virginia, you may have a workers’ compensation claim for medical care and wage benefits. That system is usually the only claim you can bring against your employer. You generally cannot sue your employer for ordinary negligence.

There is a narrow exception called deliberate intent (sometimes written “deliberate intention”). It is set out in W. Va. Code § 23-4-2. It is not the same thing as workers’ compensation, and it is not a claim for every workplace accident. The statute is strict. Negligence — even serious carelessness — is not enough.

Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC in Charleston reviews workplace-injury and deliberate-intent matters, including cases involving serious injury or wrongful death. We cannot promise that any injury will meet the statute, or what a case may be worth. If you want to talk, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482.

Related pages: Sexual Harassment · Employment Law · Truck Accidents · Wrongful Death · Personal Injury · Contact

How ordinary workers’ compensation is different

West Virginia’s workers’ compensation system, in Chapter 23 of the Code, was designed so that most on-the-job injury disputes with an employer are handled in that system rather than in a common-law lawsuit. The Legislature said so in § 23-4-2(d)(1). Employers that are in the system generally have immunity from a negligence suit. That immunity is described in § 23-2-6 and § 23-2-6a, and it is an essential part of the system.

In a typical workers’ compensation claim:

  • You do not have to prove that your employer was at fault.
  • Benefits are set by the workers’ compensation laws (medical treatment and wage-replacement type benefits, among others).
  • You generally cannot sue the employer in court for additional damages just because the workplace was unsafe in a negligent way.

A workplace injury can still involve a claim against someone other than the employer — for example, another company or a product manufacturer — depending on the facts. That is separate from a deliberate-intent claim against the employer. Retaliation for receiving or trying to receive workers’ compensation benefits is also a different statute, W. Va. Code § 23-5A-1.

What “deliberate intent” means under § 23-4-2

If an employee is injured or killed by the employer’s “deliberate intention” to produce that injury or death, the employee (or, in a death case, the representative of the estate under W. Va. Code § 55-7-6) may receive workers’ compensation benefits and bring a civil action against the employer for damages in excess of the amount received or receivable in the compensation claim. See § 23-4-2(c). To recover under this section, the employee or representative must, unless good cause is shown, have filed a claim for benefits under Chapter 23.

The immunity from suit is lost “only if” the employer or person sued acted with “deliberate intention.” The statute says that requirement may be satisfied only in one of two ways. See § 23-4-2(d)(2).

Path A — actual, specific intent to injure

The first way is to prove that the employer (or the person sued) acted with a consciously, subjectively, and deliberately formed intention to produce the specific result of injury or death to an employee. The statute says this requires an actual, specific intent. It is not satisfied by:

  • conduct that produced a result that was not specifically intended;
  • negligence, no matter how gross or aggravated; or
  • willful, wanton, or reckless misconduct.

See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(A).

Path B — five facts that all must be proven

The second way does not require proof that the employer set out to hurt a particular person. It does require the judge or jury to find that all of the following facts are proven. See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B). If any one of them is missing, this path does not apply.

  1. A specific unsafe working condition existed in the workplace that presented a high degree of risk and a strong probability of serious injury or death.
  2. Actual knowledge, before the injury. The employer had actual knowledge of that specific unsafe condition and of the high degree of risk and strong probability of serious injury or death. Actual knowledge must be specifically proven. It is not presumed. It is not established by showing what a supervisor or manager “should have known” if they had been more careful. The statute also addresses how prior accidents, near misses, complaints, or citations may be proved, and it allows actual knowledge to be shown, in a defined situation, by an intentional and deliberate failure to conduct a required inspection, audit, or assessment that was specifically intended to identify each alleged unsafe condition. See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B)(ii).
  3. A specific safety violation. The condition was a violation of a state or federal safety statute, rule, or regulation (whether the employer was cited or not), or of a commonly accepted and well-known safety standard in the employer’s industry. A general “keep the workplace safe” rule is not enough. A statute or regulation must be specifically applicable to the work and aimed at the specific hazard, and the court decides applicability as a matter of law. An industry standard, if used, must be a written consensus standard of the kind the statute describes. See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B)(iii).
  4. Intentional exposure. Even with those facts, the person or persons alleged to have actual knowledge intentionally thereafter exposed an employee to that specific unsafe working condition.
  5. Serious compensable injury or compensable death as defined in § 23-4-1, as a direct and proximate result of that specific unsafe working condition. The statute does not treat every compensable injury as enough. For this section, “serious compensable injury” may be established only by one of four methods set out in § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B)(v). Those methods include, among other requirements, a combination of a permanent impairment rating of at least 13% as a final award in the workers’ compensation claim plus additional medical criteria; or a licensed physician’s written certification that the condition is likely to result in death within 18 months; or other special rules for certain injuries and for occupational pneumoconiosis (the pneumoconiosis path has additional proof requirements and a one-year filing rule). Whether an injury meets one of those methods is a medical and legal question. This page cannot decide that for you.

Other rules that often surprise people

  • In a Path B case, the complaint must be served with a verified statement from a person with knowledge and expertise in the applicable workplace safety rules, addressing the unsafe condition and the specific provisions allegedly violated. That statement is not admissible at trial. See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(C)(i).
  • No punitive or exemplary damages may be awarded in a Path B case. See § 23-4-2(d)(2)(C)(ii).
  • Venue is limited: the case shall be brought in the circuit court of the county where the alleged injury occurred, or the county of the employer’s principal place of business. See § 23-4-2(e).
  • The Code also contains § 23-4-2a, which limits noneconomic damages. For claims arising on or after July 1, 2023, § 23-4-2a generally limits noneconomic damages in these cases to the greater of two times economic damages or $500,000 per person, adjusted each year for inflation. That is a limit, not an expected amount.
  • The statute was reenacted in 2015 and amended in 2023. The 2023 amendments apply to injuries occurring on or after July 1, 2023. See § 23-4-2(g). The date of injury can affect which version applies.

Because these requirements are cumulative and technical, many serious workplace injuries remain workers’ compensation matters only. That is how the Legislature designed the exception.

Talk with the firm

If you would like to discuss a workplace injury, a possible deliberate-intent claim, or a death on the job, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482, or use our contact form. There is no charge for an initial consultation.

Many of our employment and injury cases are handled on a contingency-fee basis. That means our attorney’s fee is a percentage of any recovery and is owed only if there is a recovery. Fees, costs, and expenses are explained in a written agreement before you hire us. Some matters are not contingency cases. We will tell you if that applies to your situation.

Contacting the firm — by phone, text, email, or this website — does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only after the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.

Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC
213 Hale Street, Suite 100
Charleston, WV 25301
Office: (681) 215-0642 · Text: (304) 767-9482 · Fax: (304) 648-4521

Frequently asked questions

Is a workplace injury the same thing as a deliberate-intent case?

No. A workplace injury often means a workers’ compensation claim only. A deliberate-intent case is a narrow civil lawsuit against the employer under W. Va. Code § 23-4-2, in addition to workers’ compensation, and only if the statute’s “deliberate intention” test is met.

Can I sue my employer for being careless?

Generally, no. Negligence, even gross negligence, is not enough. A deliberate-intent claim requires either an actual, specific intent to produce the injury or death, or proof of every one of the five statutory facts in § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B).

Do I still need to file a workers’ compensation claim?

The statute generally requires a workers’ compensation claim to have been filed, unless good cause is shown. See § 23-4-2(c). Compensation benefits and a deliberate-intent suit are not an either-or choice when the statute applies; the lawsuit is for damages in excess of what is received or receivable in the compensation claim.

Does every serious injury qualify?

No. Path B requires a “serious compensable injury” or compensable death as defined in the statute, and serious compensable injury may be established only in the ways § 23-4-2(d)(2)(B)(v) lists. A 13% impairment rating, standing alone, is not a complete description of that test.

What if a family member died in a workplace accident?

Section 23-4-2(c) allows the representative of the estate to bring a cause of action under W. Va. Code § 55-7-6, subject to the same deliberate-intention rules and the requirement to have filed a compensation claim unless good cause is shown. See our wrongful death page as well.

What if a truck, a contractor, or a piece of equipment was involved?

A claim against a non-employer third party may exist even when you cannot sue your employer. Some workplace incidents also overlap with truck accident or other personal injury claims. The facts control.

How long do I have?

Deadlines can be short. A workers’ compensation claim has its own filing rules. A civil action has a statute of limitations that depends on the claim. The pneumoconiosis path in § 23-4-2 has a one-year filing rule of its own. Do not wait to get advice. This page cannot calculate your deadline.

Disclaimer

This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. It is not a complete statement of West Virginia or federal law. The deliberate-intent statute is detailed, was amended in 2015 and 2023, and is applied to the facts of each injury, including the date of the injury. Deadlines are strict. Past results do not predict the outcome of any case. Visiting this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship until the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.


Call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482. Phones are answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Or use the contact form.