How Workplace Discrimination May Be Proved in West Virginia

How Workplace Discrimination May Be Proved in West Virginia

Many people who were treated unfairly at work do not have a memo that states an illegal reason. That does not automatically mean there is no claim, and it does not automatically mean there is one. West Virginia courts have developed a framework for looking at circumstantial evidence in Human Rights Act cases.

This page is a general overview of that framework. It is not legal advice and is not a prediction about any case. If you want to talk about what happened, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482.

Related pages: Workplace Discrimination and Retaliation · Sexual Harassment · Wrongful Termination · Employment Damages · Employment Law · Contact

A starting showing — an inference of discrimination

In a typical Human Rights Act case, courts have looked first at whether the employee has made a starting showing, sometimes called a prima facie case. In general terms, that has included:

  • That the person is a member of a protected class (for example, race, religion, color, national origin, ancestry, sex, age, blindness, or disability, as the Act defines those terms);
  • That the employer made an adverse decision concerning that person; and
  • That there is enough of a link between the decision and the protected status to support an inference that a prohibited factor was a basis for the decision.

Direct proof is not required. The third point is a threshold inquiry — a showing that supports an inference — not a requirement that the employee disprove every possible explanation at the outset. See Conaway v. Eastern Associated Coal Corp. (1986) and later cases applying that framework, including Barefoot v. Sundale Nursing Home (1995).

The employer’s stated reason, and pretext

If that starting showing is made, the employer may then offer a reason for the decision. Offering a reason does not, by itself, end the case. The employee may then show that the stated reason is not the only factor, or that it does not hold up — often called pretext.

Evidence of pretext can, in some cases, permit a jury to infer discrimination. Courts have also said that implausible reasons may be enough to let a claim go to a jury. See, among other cases, Barefoot v. Sundale Nursing Home (1995), Skaggs v. Elk Run Coal Co. (1996), and Longerbeam v. Shepherd University (2024). A disputed question of motive or intent is often for the jury, not for a judge to decide on paper alone. None of that is a promise that any particular record will be enough.

Facts that are often discussed

Depending on the workplace and the facts, the discussion may include:

  • Statements or admissions by the employer;
  • Whether similarly situated employees outside the protected class were treated better;
  • Whether the stated reason is consistent with the documents and with what was said at different times;
  • The timing of the decision in relation to a complaint or other protected activity; and
  • In a larger operation, statistical patterns.

Exact matches between employees are not always required when comparing how people were treated, but the comparison still has to be a fair one. These are examples, not a checklist that guarantees a result.

Motivating factor

West Virginia cases have also discussed a motivating-factor standard for claims under the Act: a plaintiff may state a claim by proving that a forbidden intent was a motivating factor in an employment action. The employer may then have an opportunity to show that the same decision would have been made anyway. The details of that allocation of proof are legal questions. This page is not a complete statement of the jury instructions that would apply in a particular case. See Skaggs v. Elk Run Coal Co. (1996).

Talk with the firm

If you would like to discuss what happened and whether we may be able to help, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482, or use our contact form. There is no charge for an initial consultation.

Many of our employment and injury cases are handled on a contingency-fee basis. That means our attorney’s fee is a percentage of any recovery and is owed only if there is a recovery. Fees, costs, and expenses are explained in a written agreement before you hire us. Some matters are not contingency cases. We will tell you if that applies to your situation.

Contacting the firm — by phone, text, email, or this website — does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only after the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.

Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC
213 Hale Street, Suite 100
Charleston, WV 25301
Office: (681) 215-0642 · Text: (304) 767-9482 · Fax: (304) 648-4521

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a document that admits discrimination?

No. Direct proof is not required. West Virginia courts have said that evidence can be enough if it links the employment decision to a protected characteristic in a way that supports an inference of discrimination. See Conaway v. Eastern Associated Coal Corp. (1986).

The company gave a reason for what it did. Does that end the case?

Not by itself. After an employer offers a reason, the employee may show that the reason is not the whole story — sometimes called pretext — or that a prohibited factor was a motivating factor in the decision. Whether that showing can be made depends on the facts. Motive questions are often for a jury.

What kinds of facts may matter?

Depending on the case, courts have looked at things such as an admission, different treatment of similar employees, whether the stated reason holds up, changes in the explanation over time, and, in a large workplace, statistics. None of those is required in every case, and none guarantees a result.

Is it enough that a prohibited reason was one factor, not the only factor?

West Virginia cases have discussed a “motivating factor” standard for Human Rights Act claims, under which a prohibited intent need not be the only reason for the decision. The details of how that standard is applied, and what defenses an employer may still have, are legal questions. See Skaggs v. Elk Run Coal Co. (1996). This page is a general overview, not a jury instruction.

Disclaimer

This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. It is not a complete statement of West Virginia or federal law. Deadlines are strict and can be shorter than you expect, and the facts of your situation matter. Past results do not predict the outcome of any case. Visiting this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship until the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.


Call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482. Phones are answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Or use the contact form.