West Virginia is an at-will employment state. As a starting point, an employer may fire an employee who has no contract for a set term, and an employee may also leave. That starting point surprises a lot of people who were fired and feel the decision was unfair.
At-will employment is not a blank check. A firing can still be illegal if it violates a statute, or if the employer’s motivation is to contravene a substantial public policy — the claim West Virginia courts describe using Harless v. First Nat. Bank in Fairmont, 162 W. Va. 116, 246 S.E.2d 270 (1978). This post explains that line in everyday terms. It is general information, not legal advice, and it is not a promise about any case.
Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC represents employees in West Virginia wrongful-termination and public-policy discharge cases. We are a Charleston, WV law firm. We cannot promise a particular result. If you want to talk with an attorney, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482.
Related pages: Harless / Public-Policy Discharge · Wrongful Termination · Workplace Discrimination and Retaliation · Retaliation · Unpaid Wages · Employment Law · Contact
What at-will employment means — and what it does not
If there is no contract for a definite term, and no other law that applies, an employer in West Virginia may generally discharge an employee. That is the at-will starting point. It does not mean that every reason for a firing is lawful. It also does not mean that a firing is illegal just because it was sudden, poorly explained, or unfair.
The legal question is whether the firing violated a statute, a contract, or a substantial public policy that West Virginia law actually recognizes. Feeling wronged is not, by itself, a claim.
The Harless public-policy rule
In Harless, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia held: “The rule that an employer has an absolute right to discharge an at will employee must be tempered by the principle that where the employer’s motivation for the discharge is to contravene some substantial public policy principle, then the employer may be liable to the employee for damages occasioned by this discharge.” Harless v. First Nat. Bank in Fairmont, 162 W. Va. 116, 246 S.E.2d 270 (1978).
The case itself involved an employee who alleged he was discharged after objecting to consumer-credit law violations at the bank. That is the setting of the decision. It is not a complete list of public policies, and it is not a promise that every complaint about workplace conduct will support a Harless claim. Which public policies support this kind of claim is decided case by case. A post like this cannot publish an open-ended list, such as “any safety complaint” or “any illegal act,” as if it were a statute.
Statutes often already forbid the firing
Before asking whether a firing contravenes a public policy under Harless, it is often important to ask whether a statute already prohibits what happened. West Virginia and federal law contain a number of specific limits on discharge. Examples include:
- The West Virginia Human Rights Act, which prohibits discrimination in employment because of protected status and prohibits reprisal for opposing forbidden practices or participating in a proceeding under the Act. See W. Va. Code § 16B-17-9. Our discrimination and retaliation pages discuss that statute.
- The Wage Payment and Collection Act, which regulates the payment of wages, including a final paycheck. See our unpaid wages page.
- The workers’ compensation anti-discrimination statutes, which prohibit discriminating against an employee because the person received or tried to receive workers’ compensation benefits. See W. Va. Code § 23-5A-1.
- The federal Family and Medical Leave Act, which, when it applies, makes it unlawful to interfere with FMLA rights or to discharge or discriminate against a person for opposing a practice the FMLA makes unlawful.
A statutory claim covering the same ground may be clearer than a Harless claim, or it may travel with one. That is an analysis point, not a holding that one path always replaces the other. Which claim, if any, fits depends on the facts and on a statute or policy that can actually be identified.
Recent cases, without overstating them
West Virginia’s highest court has continued to allow Harless claims to proceed when the pleadings or the facts, taken in the proper light, support them. In Burke v. Wetzel County Commission, 240 W. Va. 709, 815 S.E.2d 520 (2018), the Court reversed a dismissal and allowed, among other claims, an FMLA claim and a Harless claim in which the plaintiff identified public-policy sources that included the FMLA, the Human Rights Act, the Whistle-Blower Law, and constitutional provisions. Burke is a motion-to-dismiss reversal. It is not a trial holding that every FMLA fact pattern supports a Harless claim.
In Longerbeam v. Shepherd University, 252 W. Va. 264, 922 S.E.2d 264 (2024), the Court reversed summary judgment on whistle-blower and Harless claims, along with related claims. That decision is recent confirmation that a Harless claim can survive summary judgment when the facts are disputed. It is not a general treatise on every kind of firing, and it is not a guarantee about any other case.
Damages if a claim succeeds
If a Harless or other employment claim succeeds, the remedies can include lost wages and, in some situations, other relief. Current West Virginia law also requires a plaintiff in an employment-law case to mitigate past and future lost wages. The older “malice exception” to that duty has been abolished, and unmitigated or flat back-pay and front-pay awards are not available. See W. Va. Code § 55-7E-3. Our employment damages page, and the companion post in this series on back pay and front pay, explain those limits. No particular amount is typical, and no result is promised.
What this means if you were fired
If you were fired in West Virginia and you think the reason was illegal, the useful questions are concrete. Was the firing because of a protected characteristic? Did it follow a report of discrimination, a workers’ compensation claim, a request for medical leave, or another protected step? Is there a contract, or a substantial public policy that can be identified, not just a sense that the firing was unfair? Deadlines can be short.
Talk with the firm
If you would like to discuss what happened and whether we may be able to help, call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482, or use our contact form. There is no charge for an initial consultation.
Many of our employment and injury cases are handled on a contingency-fee basis. That means our attorney’s fee is a percentage of any recovery and is owed only if there is a recovery. Fees, costs, and expenses are explained in a written agreement before you hire us. Some matters are not contingency cases. We will tell you if that applies to your situation.
Contacting the firm — by phone, text, email, or this website — does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is formed only after the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.
Hoosier Law Firm, PLLC
213 Hale Street, Suite 100
Charleston, WV 25301
Office: (681) 215-0642 · Text: (304) 767-9482 · Fax: (304) 648-4521
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue if I was fired for no reason?
West Virginia is an at-will state, so a firing is not illegal merely because the employer did not give a reason, or because the reason seems unfair. A firing can still be illegal if it violates a statute or contravenes a substantial public policy under Harless v. First Nat. Bank in Fairmont, 162 W. Va. 116, 246 S.E.2d 270 (1978). Whether that is true in a particular case depends on the facts.
What is a Harless claim?
It is a common-law claim recognized by the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. An employer may be liable when the motivation for discharging an at-will employee is to contravene a substantial public policy principle. See Harless v. First Nat. Bank in Fairmont, 162 W. Va. 116, 246 S.E.2d 270 (1978). The public policy has to be identified. This page cannot list every policy that might qualify.
If a statute already forbids the firing, do I still need a Harless claim?
Not necessarily. A statute such as the Human Rights Act, the wage-payment law, the workers’ compensation anti-retaliation statutes, or the FMLA may already prohibit the conduct. A Harless claim is the common-law doctrine used when a substantial public policy is contravened. Sometimes statutory and common-law theories are both considered. The right path depends on the facts.
Disclaimer
This page is attorney advertising and general information, not legal advice. It is not a complete statement of West Virginia or federal law. Deadlines are strict and can be shorter than you expect, and the facts of your situation matter. Past results do not predict the outcome of any case. Visiting this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship until the firm agrees to represent you. Do not send confidential details about your situation until we have agreed to represent you.
Call (681) 215-0642 or text (304) 767-9482. Phones are answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Or use the contact form.
